Scott Alexander explores two contrasting attitudes in psychiatry, discussing their merits and pitfalls, while reflecting on his own tendency to favor a more straightforward approach. Longer summary

Scott Alexander discusses two contrasting attitudes in psychiatry: Attitude 1, which takes patients' requests at face value, and Attitude 2, which seeks to unravel underlying complexities. He provides examples where Attitude 2 is clearly beneficial, but also highlights its potential for misuse. The author admits to leaning towards Attitude 1, partly due to personal preferences and social pressures. He expresses uncertainty about whether this approach is always correct and worries about potentially missing important underlying issues. The post reflects on the challenges of balancing these approaches in psychiatric practice. Shorter summary