May 02, 2014
ssc
Read on (unread)

Causal Models At Work

2 min • 171 words • 16 comments
https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/02/causal-models-at-work/
Scott Alexander shares two humorous medical anecdotes that highlight the potential for misunderstanding complex health information. Longer summary
Scott Alexander shares two humorous anecdotes involving medical professionals and patients, highlighting the potential for misunderstanding when discussing complex medical information. The first involves a conversation with an AIDS specialist about life expectancy for HIV patients, while the second features Scott as a doctor discussing medication for alcoholism with a patient. Both stories demonstrate how literal interpretations of medical advice can lead to absurd conclusions, emphasizing the importance of clear communication in healthcare. Shorter summary
Recurring tags: healthcare (56), humor (48), medical ethics (37), medical communication (5), alcoholism (4), patient education (2)

[Epistemic status: loosely based on a true story]

AIDS Specialist: You know, people think AIDS is a death sentence. But how long do you think the average person lives after getting HIV?
Me: I don’t know.
AIDS Specialist: Thirty years! Isn’t that amazing? You can get HIV, and probably you’ll live another three decades!
Me: Really?
AIDS Specialist: Yeah.
Me: So, the trick is, give yourself HIV when you’re eighty, then live to be a hundred ten.
AIDS Specialist: I like you.
Me: Really?
AIDS Specialist: No.

And a few weeks later:

Me: Do you have a family history of alcoholism?
Alcoholic Patient: No. Why?
Me: Well, I am trying to figure out whether to prescribe you this medication, and studies suggest it works best in patients with a genetic predisposition to alcohol abuse.
Alcoholic Patient: I don’t understand.
Me: The medicine only works if one of your parents drinks too much.
Alcoholic Patient: Well, I think I can get my dad to start.
Me: NO!

Read 16+ comments
If you enjoy this fan website, you can support us over here. Thanks a lot!
Send this article to your Kindle or e-reader

We'll email you this article as an EPUB attachment, ready to open on your Kindle, Kobo, or any other e-reader.

Enter your Send-to-Kindle email (it looks like [email protected]) below. For Amazon to accept the file, you first need to add our sender address to your approved list:

[email protected]

Open Amazon approved emails settings

On that page, open "Personal Document Settings", then add the address above under "Approved Personal Document E-mail List".

If your Kindle is linked to a non-US Amazon account, change the link's domain to match your country (for example amazon.fr or amazon.co.uk instead of amazon.com).

Email address
Enjoying this website? You can donate to support it! You can also check out my Book Translator tool.