Scott Alexander discusses the ethical dilemma of writing doctor's notes for back pain as a psychiatrist, leading to reflections on 'bullshit jobs' and procedural inefficiencies in the economy.
Longer summary
Scott Alexander discusses the ethical dilemma of writing doctor's notes for patients with back pain, despite being a psychiatrist. He explores the pros and cons of writing such notes, and shares his strategy of radical honesty. This leads him to reflect on David Graeber's concept of 'bullshit jobs' and how much of the economy might consist of similar procedural rituals that don't add real value. The post highlights the tension between following procedures and providing practical help, and questions why profit-focused companies would engage in such seemingly inefficient practices.
Shorter summary