Scott Alexander examines the life cycle of medical ideas, discussing how promising treatments often get stuck in a 'grey area' between proven and alternative medicine.
Longer summary
Scott Alexander discusses the life cycle of medical ideas, focusing on three examples from about five years ago: Zamboni's multiple sclerosis theory, Gat and Goren's prostatic hyperplasia theory, and minocycline for schizophrenia. He explores how the medical community responds to new ideas, the challenges of getting promising treatments approved and widely used, and the role of drug companies in this process. Scott notes a 'grey area' between proven medicine and alternative medicine, where promising ideas often languish, and reflects on the potential for new organizations to speed up the evaluation and adoption of these ideas.
Shorter summary