Mar 14, 2024
acx
Read on (unread)

Verses On Five People Being Killed By A Falling Package Of Foreign Aid

Scott Alexander's poem, inspired by a tragic aid airdrop incident in Gaza, explores the challenges and unintended consequences of altruism through various philosophical lenses. Longer summary
Scott Alexander presents a poetic reflection on the challenges and unintended consequences of trying to help others, inspired by a tragic incident where an aid airdrop killed five people in Gaza. The poem explores various philosophical approaches to altruism and social responsibility, ultimately settling on a utilitarian perspective while acknowledging its limitations. The verses touch on historical figures, personal growth, and the complexities of moral decision-making in a world where good intentions can lead to harmful outcomes. Shorter summary

(inspired by Aid Airdrop Kills Five People In Gaza After Parachute Fails)

When God placed Man upon the earth
In days of God knows when
He said to love the Lord your God
And love your fellow men

It's safe enough to love the Lord
In worship or in song
The Lord your God is far away
And very, very strong

But he who loves his fellow man
Must careful be, and agile
For fellow men are very close
And very, very fragile

So Midgley, Marx, and Mao, and more
All had their tale to tell
They tried to help their fellow men
And pushed them into Hell

And Galton, Ehrlich, Robespierre
Corbusier and Kipling
All saw their actions ripple out
And worsen in the rippling

And every time you throw a coin
Into a beggar's jar
The coin could strike the beggar's face
And leave him with a scar

And every slice of bread you give
To a child starved and broke
Could lodge the wrong way in his throat
And cause the kid to choke

The best laid plans of mice and men
Are oft unwisely laid
And end with Palestinians
Struck dead by falling aid

When young, I learned philosophy
At many a scholar's door
And all the wisdom that I learned
Came down to options four:

  • To make your heart as hard as stone
    Like the heart of a machine
    And sit there supercilious
    Because your hands are clean
  • To pet your dog and kiss your kid
    And call your duty done
    While far away, the Gazan girls
    Are dropping one by one
  • To rush in bright and glorious
    'Neath the golden flag of Good
    Then apologize at leisure to
    Men crushed by falling food
  • Or to creep in like accountants
    Using gain and loss as anchors
    As cunning as the serpents
    And as cold as Wall Street bankers

When I was young, I fought among
The golden-flagged crusaders
But now I’m old, and now I stand
Beside the snakes and traders

So when my plans go all awry
And my name becomes a curse
I can say the other option was
Eleven utils worse

And if upon the Judgment Day
God comes to me in wrath
I'll have a PowerPoint prepared
To prove I did the math

And if, upon the Judgment Day
God says my math is wrong
I'll tell Him He is far away
And very, very strong

But man is very, very close
And very, very brittle
And we can only do our best
Or sit there, noncommital

And so we sighed, and multiplied
And after that, we prayed
For souls of Palestinians
Struck dead by falling aid.

If you enjoy this fan website, you can support us over here. Thanks a lot!
Send this article to your Kindle or e-reader

We'll email you this article as an EPUB attachment, ready to open on your Kindle, Kobo, or any other e-reader.

Enter your Send-to-Kindle email (it looks like [email protected]) below. For Amazon to accept the file, you first need to add our sender address to your approved list:

[email protected]

Open Amazon approved emails settings

On that page, open "Personal Document Settings", then add the address above under "Approved Personal Document E-mail List".

If your Kindle is linked to a non-US Amazon account, change the link's domain to match your country (for example amazon.fr or amazon.co.uk instead of amazon.com).

Email address
Enjoying this website? You can donate to support it! You can also check out my Book Translator tool.