Want to dive into Scott Alexander's work and his thousands of blog posts? This fan website lets you sort and do semantic search through the whole codex. Enjoy!

See also Top Posts and All Tags.

Tag: debate tactics

Or pick a range
–
min
Blog
Only
Year
2026
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
Language
Français
No results found
debate tactics (6)
study critique (272)
book review (227)
AI (113)
economics (105)
effective altruism (105)
debate (93)
education (93)
creative writing (92)
forecasting (91)
prediction markets (90)
politics (89)
science (85)
AI safety (84)
media criticism (76)
neuroscience (76)
rationality (76)
psychiatry (74)
psychology (72)
mental health (69)
highlights from the comments (68)
No results found
study critique (272)
book review (227)
AI (113)
economics (105)
effective altruism (105)
debate (93)
education (93)
creative writing (92)
forecasting (91)
prediction markets (90)
politics (89)
science (85)
AI safety (84)
media criticism (76)
neuroscience (76)
rationality (76)
psychiatry (74)
psychology (72)
mental health (69)
highlights from the comments (68)
Links to
No results found
domain: slatestarcodex.com (1130 posts)
domain: wikipedia.org (902 posts)
domain: astralcodexten.com (571 posts)
domain: lesswrong.com (495 posts)
domain: twitter.com / x.com (448 posts)
domain: nih.gov (334 posts)
domain: reddit.com (322 posts)
domain: amazon.com (277 posts)
domain: substack.com (273 posts)
domain: google.com (237 posts)
domain: nytimes.com (230 posts)
domain: wordpress.com (175 posts)
domain: tumblr.com (159 posts)
domain: vox.com (159 posts)
domain: washingtonpost.com (143 posts)
domain: marginalrevolution.com (140 posts)
domain: sciencedirect.com (131 posts)
domain: theguardian.com (130 posts)
subreddit: slatestarcodex (130 posts)
domain: youtube.com (129 posts)
Remember which posts I've read on this device
6 posts
Date
Length
Likes
Comments

Escaping The “Outside Criticism” Trap

Scott explains how the 'you ignore outside criticism' accusation works as an unwinnable Kafkatrap, and proposes a power-law approach to deciding how much attention to give critics at different distances from your views.

acx
Nov 11, 2026 1,972 words 369 likes 350 comments Read Read Opened Opened

Proving Too Much

Scott Alexander explores the 'Proving Too Much' fallacy as an efficient tactic to quickly dismantle complex arguments, particularly those using Dark Arts techniques.

ssc
Apr 13, 2013 742 words 0 likes 53 comments Listen · 6 min Read Read Opened Opened

The noncentral fallacy - the worst argument in the world?

Scott proposes the "noncentral fallacy" as a candidate for the worst argument in the world: applying emotional reactions from archetypal category members to non-archetypal examples, illustrated through examples like calling Martin Luther King Jr. a "criminal."

lw
Aug 27, 2012 2,283 words 459 likes 1,773 comments Read Read Opened Opened

When Truth Isn't Enough

Scott distinguishes between a statement's denotation (factual content) and connotation (emotional implications), showing how technically true statements can mislead through subtext, and proposes ADBOC as a response technique.

lw
Mar 22, 2009 1,034 words 140 likes 59 comments Read Read Opened Opened

The Power of Positivist Thinking

Scott defends a 'soft positivism' in which meaningful statements can be reduced to testable claims, and argues that statements that resist such reduction, like 'Islam is a religion of peace', often smuggle in emotion and prejudice.

lw
Mar 21, 2009 2,712 words 98 likes 57 comments Read Read Opened Opened

How to Not Lose an Argument

Scott argues that to persuade people rather than just demolish them, you should leave them a social line of retreat by being genuinely nice and not treating the discussion as a status contest.

lw
Mar 19, 2009 1,961 words 171 likes 416 comments Read Read Opened Opened
Per page:
Showing 1 to 6 of 6 results
Subscribe to this search

We'll send you an email whenever a new post matches this search.

Tagged debate tactics

To get these emails, create a free account. We only use it for this website's features, like subscriptions and favorites, and never share your email.

Already have an account? Log in

New here? Create an account

Get these search results in an EPUB

Your filters match 6 posts.

Posts to include
–
Leave empty to keep the defaults. Range cannot exceed 500 posts.
Download now

Generates an EPUB right now and downloads it to your device.

Send to email

Generates an EPUB in the background and emails you a temporary download link.

Your email is not shared with anyone.

Email address

To send to your Kindle, just use this link.